Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Straws in the Wind

Things have been moving quickly these last few days in the world of F1. On Saturday morning, I'd been planning to put together a little piece about how Jaime Alguersuari was faring as the youngest man ever to start a Grand Prix. By the conclusion of qualifying, that story had rather been overtaken by Felipe Massa's freak accident, which looks set to knock him out of action for the rest of the season. We can only be glad that the debris struck the side of his helmet as opposed to the visor, in which case he might not still have been with us at all.

The Hungarian GP itself didn't provide much entertainment, aside from Hamilton's as it turned out rather crucial pass of Mark Webber in the early laps on the exit of Turn One, so I got to pondering who might replace Massa at Ferrari for the rest of the season. I struggled to remember the names of their current test drivers to be honest (Luca Badoer and Marc Gene, in case your curiosity has been piqued) and I couldn't see either of them ending up in the car. I wondered instead whether the Scuderia might make a swoop for a current F1 driver. Robert Kubica, who hasn't seemed especially happy at BMW for a while, seemed a possibility.

The post-race penalty imposed on Renault for sending Alonso off down pit-road with a loose wheel-nut made me wonder if instead Ferrari had the Spaniard at the top of its wish list to replace Massa. With Renault seemingly out of the European Grand Prix at Valencia, and with it being Alonso's home race, it seemed all too possible that he might jump ship, especially as it's much rumoured he'll be heading over there in 2010 anyway.

Conspiracy theorists might wonder if the decision to penalise Renault (though not the driver who limped round the lap with a loose wheel. albeit to be fair he might not have known that the wheel was loose, as opposed to punctured) indicates that the FIA were somehow complicit in all this. After all, drivers have been sent out of the pits without wheels being properly secured plenty times in the past, it's just one of those things that happens from time to time.

To be fair, while it's possible, I'm not sure it's the most likely explanation. In the wake of Henry Surtees' tragic death at Brands Hatch the previous weekend, and in the light of Massa's practice crash, the stewards perhaps had reason to take an especially dim view of a team deliberately allowing a car with a wheel on the verge of flying off to continue back to pitlane. And besides, in these post-Todt, FOTA days, does the FIA really still stand for Ferrari International Assistance any longer?

What holed this particular theory below the water-line, though, was one of two further developments today - the news that Michael Schumacher will be returning to the cockpit to sub for Felipe Massa. To be honest I'm a little surprised that the German multiple world champion wants to get back into what does not look an especially competitive Ferrari, without the undisputed number 1 status. At the age of 40, he'll be by some margin the oldest driver to have competed in contemporary Formula 1 for a long time, and still nursing injuries picked up while motorcycle racing earlier in the year, it's not clear he's really at full fitness. Past returns by retired world champions - think Mansell at Mclaren in 1995 or Alan Jones in the admittedly uncompetitive Lola in 1986, have not gone well.

All the same, it will be interesting to see how he goes, even if it does perhaps threaten to overshadow what is fast becoming a very intriguing title battle between Jenson Button and the Red Bull pair of Mark Webber and Sebastian Vettel. It seems pretty clear that, even on hot days on circuits where mechanical grip counts for more than absolute aerodynamic efficiency, the Red Bull appears to be ahead in terms of pure pace now. On the other hand, Button has a very handy points advantage, and provided that Rubens Barrichello can be made to recognise the reality of the situation, it is at least clear that only one of the Brawn drivers can realistically walk away with the driver's title, while it is far from obvious even which of the two Red Bull drivers the team would be better off backing if they wanted to.

Today's other story, of course, which just might overshadow even the return of Schumacher, is the news that BMW is to pull out of the sport. After four years as a full manufacturer team (having previously provided engines to Williams) the Swiss-German squad appeared to be making real progress last year, with Kubica winning his and their first race, and being in contention for the title until the penultimate race. They've gone dramatically backwards this year and it has been interesting that both Bernie Ecclestone and the FIA have insinuated that this lies behind their withdrawal from the sport.

Which is of course entirely possible. Teams that are winning don't tend to quit. Teams that are embarrassing the owners, on the other hand, like Honda last year, do. That said, BMW were a leading light in FOTA and it will be interesting to see what the impact of their withdrawal will be on the sport. Perhaps the most ominous reading is that their decision to quit has little to do with either the global economic picture or the team's current lack of competitiveness (which may after all be temporary) but is a judgment on the way that the sport is being run. Ecclestone's tasteless comments about Hitler, Max Mosley's seemingly deliberate combativeness, and perhaps now the nagging suspicion that if Jean Todt wins the forthcoming FIA elections, little will really change.

There remains the question, too, of whether BMW will be the last of the manufacturer teams to pull the plug. The vultures have been circulating over the Renault team for some time now, and the FIA's decision to ban them from the European Grand Prix for doing nothing that other teams haven't done down the years will hardly have done anything to encourage them to stay. Toyota continue to burn vast amounts of cash achieving relatively little - with that first win looking no more likely than it has. And if Dietrich Mateschitz ever decides that he's got better things to do, say once he's picked up a World Title for his Red Bull team, a real hole would be left in the sport.

That's perhaps accentuating the negative. After all, there's supposed to be three new teams coming in next year, and there were several others who applied for entries only to be turned down by the FIA (cynics suggest because when the FIA was playing poker with FOTA, it wanted to keep some credible 'would be' entries up its sleeve). If these teams were thinking of entering in their own right, and weren't mere paper tigers, it shouldn't be beyond the resources of one or two of them to pick up the pieces left behind by BMW and Renault. And that's if Peter Sauber doesn't retake the helm at his old team, and Flavio Briatore can't find a friendly billionaire to take over at Renault.

Interesting times, then. I only hope that it doesn't overshadow what is fast turning into yet another intriguing world title battle, both between Red Bull and Brawn, and between Webber, Button and Vettel. There are times when it seems the F1 world is focused more on next season that on what is happening on the circuit on a Sunday afternoon. Not surprising, perhaps, at this time of year when all but a few teams and drivers will know by now that this is not to be their year (Hamilton or Raikkonen could quite easily win all the season's remaining races without standing any realistic chance of taking the driver's title) but a shame if an intriguing fight between three drivers and two teams which have never before been in this position ends up being overlooked.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

C'est La Guerre...

Certain controversies and scandals, I must admit, I tend to stay clear of here at Motorsports Ramblings. You might have noticed that I have not so much as mentioned the subject of espionage, Mike Coughlan or Nigel Stepney. Why? Firstly, because I don't have access to all the facts, and so anything I did say would be little more than idle speculation. However, as someone not entirely averse to idle speculation, I have to admit the more fundamental reason is that the whole sorry saga bores me rigid. For similar reasons, I stayed away from the subject of 'mass dampers' last year. I'm no engineer, and the sum total of my contribution would have been little more than to note that it was strange that the FIA couldn't seem to make up their own mind about their legality until Renault started to run away with their second title.

A part of me is tempted to treat the latest spat between the FIA, Mclaren, Fernando Alonso and Lewis Hamilton in much the same way. I'm not going to, however, for two reasons. The first is that the affair provides a very interesting insight into the minds of the two men leading the chase for the world title, and the team which provides their cars. The second is that the very fact that the whole situation arose in the first place sheds light on what exactly is wrong with the current F1 rulebook.

The facts of the matter are set out very clearly in Joe Saward's most recent Globetrotter column. Lewis Hamilton disobeyed a team order from Mclaren to let Fernando Alonso past during the 'fuel burn' phase of qualifying because it was Alonso's turn to gain advantage from the additional lap's worth of fuel that can be gained from running first on the road (though one can't help but feel that there can't be many tracks where this is an issue). Hamilton said that he did this to prevent Raikkonen from getting past him as well. This seems a little disingenuous, because Raikkonen really wasn't that close to Alonso at the time and one can't help feeling that drivers of Alonso and Hamilton's ability could co-ordinate an overtaking manouevre if so required.

Alonso was held in the pits for 20 seconds after his pit stop. Mclaren say that this was done in order to get him out in clear air. There seems no reason to doubt this, and had he gone when the lollipop was lifted, there would have been time for Hamilton to make his pit stop and get in a second flying lap. However, Alonso did not go when he got the signal, and instead waited a further 10 seconds, thus preventing Hamilton from having a second run (by around 4 seconds, it would seem). Hamilton assumed this all happened at the behest of the team and, according to press reports, got into a war of words with his mentor and team boss, Ron Dennis, over the radio.

Hamilton: "Don't ever fucking do that to me again"
Dennis: "Don't ever fucking talk to me like that again"
Hamilton: "Go fucking swivel"

The FIA later decided that Fernando Alonso had deliberately impeded another driver (his team mate) during qualifying, and thus moved him back to 5th on the grid. Curiously, the stewards also decided that Mclaren had acted in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the competition and ruled that they would not score constructors points. This seems a little odd, because it strikes me that the incident which prevented Hamilton from getting a second qualifying run was either a) an accident, b) done at the instigation of the team to punish him for ignoring team orders or c) done at the instigation of Alonso for tactical advantage. Logically, it cannot have been both b) and c) and so it strikes me that the penalties are somewhat odd.

Opinion, it would seem, is split on the question of whether the blame lies mainly with Alonso, with Hamilton, or with the Mclaren team. Myself, I can't help feeling that none of them come out of this affair too well.

Fernando's Error

Let's start with Alonso. He has not looked entirely at home at Mclaren all season. At Renault, he complained on more than one occasion that he didn't get the support he wanted and expected from the team. For this, read, he was not the undisputed Number 1 that Michael Schumacher was at Ferrari. He should have known, coming to Mclaren, that the team had always had a policy of equal number 1 status between their two drivers. Perhaps he never expected Hamilton to get close to him in terms of pace, but when he did, did Alonso really expect that he would suddenly be granted special status?

Ron Dennis may claim otherwise, but it seems fairly clear that Alonso deliberately delayed his pit lane exit on Saturday in an effort to snatch pole from his young team mate. He must have known, given past form, that while Hamilton was doing nothing that was contrary to the rule book by disobeying orders from his team to let Alonso past, Alonso was breaking the rules when he blocked Hamilton in the pitlane. He really should have known, given how keen the FIA are on handing out penalties for blocking in qualifying, that he probably wasn't going to get away with it. More importantly, a man who to my mind genuinely was hard done by by the stewards last year in his title battle with Michael Schumacher has sacrificed his reputation and credibility, and to what end?

Lewis blows a fuse

By the letter of the law, Lewis Hamilton did nothing wrong on track. Indeed, on Sunday, in particular, his performance in the car around the Hungaroring was impeccable. It could even be argued that his disobeying of team orders on Saturday was a show of strength. The message he was sending was "I'm more important to you than you are to me. You can't punish me without harming yourselves" and that it is he, and not double champion Alonso, who represents Mclaren's best bet for the title.

The problem with that theory is the needless verbal spat with Ron Dennis over the radio when it all went wrong (it is interesting that he assumed it was the team, and not Alonso, which messed him around in the pits). That hints that the real reason he disobeyed orders is that Alonso's challenge has rattled him. Just as Alonso fears that the young protege is McLaren's favoured one, so Hamilton believes that Mclaren prefer the experienced, safe pair of hands. Certainly the row he had with Ron Dennis over the radio points in that direction. Others have suggested that the way he spoke to Dennis smacked of arrogance, of rudeness.

I'm less sure, to me it suggests immaturity. A young man - not really much more than a teenager - under intense pressure, who is perhaps beginning to crack. So Ron Dennis is something of a father figure to him? Well who hasn't exchanged harsh words with their family on odd occasions, when under particular stress? To me, Hamilton's behaviour was understandable, but it wasn't clever. He had an opportunity handed to him on a plate, after Alonso's pit lane shenanigans, to establish a clear moral upper hand at Mclaren - to get the whole team behind him. And he blew it.

Mclaren under pressure

There is a myth that Ron Dennis is the best manager in the pit lane. More specifically, I've heard it said that Mclaren are the best man managers in the business. This weekend rather blew that claim out of the water. If Mclaren were so keen that Alonso was first on the road in final qualifying last weekend, why on earth didn't they arrange for him to be first out of the garage? If they wanted to punish Hamilton for disobeying team orders, why not just put him on the wrong tyres for his final run? If, on the other hand, it was all Alonso's doing, why did they pretend otherwise to the stewards and end up losing their constructors points for the weekend? And if, as seems somewhat unlikely, it was all just a bit of a cock up.... Well, that doesn't say too much for them either. At least they made sure there was enough fuel in the cars...

Moreover, one has to wonder whether Mclaren have ever really deserved their reputation as driver managers. After all, in the last year, they have fallen out with Raikkonen - a man they went to enormous lengths to sign, and with Juan Montoya, a man who never struck me as a natural Mclaren driver, but whom Ron Dennis was convinced he could turn into a world champion. Going back through the years, both Alain Prost and Niki Lauda, who won world titles with the team, left under a cloud. Prost felt the team had failed to rein in Senna's excesses, and Lauda thought Dennis had simply never really made him feel welcome. This year, it is beginning to look as if McLaren are in danger of alienating both of their drivers.

Its funny, really, that it is Ferrari, who for so long have operated a clear number 1 driver policy, and who have abandoned it this year, who seem to be having the easier time of it with their drivers. Perhaps both teams have the wrong driver pairings, though. Might the imperturbable Kimi Raikkonen have been better suited to dealing with shockingly fast newcomer Lewis Hamilton? Might Fernando Alonso's strong work ethic have served Ferrari better this year as they struggle to rebuild the team after the departures of Brawn, Schumacher, and now Stepney? Who knows...

The underlying problem

Its easy to lose sight of the bigger picture, but let's not forget this was, in the beginning, an argument about who ran first on the road in qualifying. Why on earth has such a seemingly trivial matter assumed so much importance for the leading title protagonists?

Firstly, it is because of the hugely disproportionate importance of qualifying in modern Formula 1. It hasn't been exactly easy to overtake in F1 for a very long time - at least since the end of the turbo era in the late 1980s. In recent years, though, attempts by the rule makers to reduce cornering speeds have resulted in cars which are immensely sensitive to 'dirty air' and simply can't pass each other. Alonso, after all, spent much of Sunday afternoon stuck behind a Toyota. With all due respect, the Japanese team have not been anywhere near the pace all season, and while they may have been having an unusually good day, there is no way that Ralf Schumacher was within a second a lap of Alonso's pace.

That, in itself, would not necessarily be such a big problem. Sure, qualifying becomes immensely important because it helps to determine all-important track position, but if that were the only issue, the team could simply tell each of its drivers to get on with it and bang in the fast laps on Saturday.

There's another problem, though. Refuelling. Ever since this was reintroduced to F1 in 1994 (a terrible mistake in my book, but not one that I expect to see reversed any time soon), for any track and car combination, there will be an optimum fuel strategy. The problem is, the team can only give it to one driver. As only one car can be refuelled at a time, it is simply impossible to put both drivers on identical strategies. Usually, the difference between the two strategies will be small, but in a contest where the gap between the drivers is so small, and where overtaking is so difficult, the smallest of advantages can be crucial. Besides which, there's the psychological element - one driver will know that his team mate has been given the more favourable strategy. However small the real difference, that is inevitably going to provide fertile ground in which discord may grow.

Moving forward through time, since 2003, drivers have had to qualify with the fuel load they will start the race with. Now, not only will one driver have his strategy compromised slightly be carrying (for example) a heavier than ideal fuel load, but the fuel loads chosen affect the driver's qualifying pace, and hence their track position. Inevitably, one driver will always be fuelled lighter than the other - and so, all other things being equal, should qualify ahead.

Finally, the most recent tweak to the rules, the one which led to Saturday's debacle: Since 2006, drivers have got a lap's worth of fuel back for every lap they complete in the final phase of qualifying - the horrendously artificial and overcomplicated 'fuel burn phase'. Thus, in certain, very marginal situations, the order you run on the road affects the number of laps you can claim back. There will only be a few tracks where this is likely to be an issue, but Hungary was one of them. Mclaren calculated that one of their drivers - the one who was first on the road, could get an extra lap in, and hence gain some extra fuel back to start the race. The team had determined it was Alonso's turn. Hamilton decided otherwise.

I remarked at the beginning of the season that the Hamilton/Alonso pairing had the potential to disintegrate in the way that the Senna/Prost line-up of the late 1980s did. I thought, on balance, that it would not - that Alonso and Hamilton were not such disparate individuals as Senna and Prost; that an older, more authoritative Ron Dennis would have greater influence over his much younger charges. I reckoned without a rulebook seemingly designed to cause strife between team mates going for the world title. Had Senna and Prost been racing today, I doubt they'd have lasted half a season together at the same team.

Labels: , , , , , ,